Client mindset and the Cannes Lions

The Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity stands as a pinnacle for the advertising and marketing industry, a global stage where creative excellence is celebrated and benchmarked. Agencies from around the world aspire to have their work recognised within its prestigious halls. However, for their clients, the brands that ultimately fund and approve these campaigns, the value proposition of such accolades can be a more complex consideration, often weighed against the more tangible metrics of business performance and return on investment (ROI).

It is a natural inclination for individuals and organisations alike to appreciate recognition. Sumanto Chattopadhyay, Independent Creative Director, observes this, noting, "It’s human nature to be delighted by awards—something that applies to clients too." He adds that some clients "put an official emphasis on winning awards—believing that there is a correlation between award wins and market success." This perspective suggests a recognition that creative distinction can contribute to a brand's reputation and potentially its market standing. However, the financial commitment required for entering the Cannes Lions can often lead to a divergence in priorities. As Chattopadhyay points out, "But given the exorbitant price-tag attached to Cannes entries, it’s another question whether they will drop hard cash for that glory. They would, more often than not, leave it to the agency to make that investment." This highlights a common dynamic where clients may value the outcome of an award but are less inclined to directly fund the pursuit of it.

The role of awards in client discussions

The extent to which creative awards, such as the Cannes Lions, factor into client briefs and campaign discussions can vary significantly. Satbir Singh, Founder & Chief Creative Officer, Thinkstr, states unequivocally, "It is basic human nature to want to win. Everyone loves awards." This inherent desire for recognition, according to Singh, means that awards, in some form or another, are often lurking in the subconscious, if not explicitly stated. However, the frequency and intensity of this discussion likely depend on a multitude of factors, including the industry, the brand's maturity, and the client's personal inclinations. A young, challenger brand might be more eager for the visibility and validation that a Cannes win can bring, acting as a David-slaying-Goliath narrative in their market. On the other hand, a mature, established giant might prioritise consistent ROI and brand building over the pursuit of creative accolades.

Chattopadhyay suggests that while some clients might officially emphasise awards, it doesn't always translate to proactive engagement in that direction. Agencies often find themselves internally calibrating their creative compass towards Cannes-worthy ideas, even if the client's brief is solely focused on achieving a specific business target. It’s a delicate dance of pushing creative boundaries while staying firmly within the strategic goalposts.

Balancing creativity with business realities

What happens when the client's focus is laser-sharp on the bottom line, and awards seem like a distant, perhaps even irrelevant, concern? How do agencies maintain a spark of creative brilliance and push for work that could still potentially turn heads at Cannes? This is where the agency's internal culture and drive come into play. As Chattopadhyay states, "And yes, agencies often quietly aim for Cannes-worthy ideas even without explicit client interest. It's about pushing the craft while staying grounded in strategy." It's about a deep-seated commitment to producing exceptional work, a desire to hone their craft, and a belief that truly innovative ideas can often be the most effective in the long run.

Think of it like a chef striving for Michelin stars even when cooking for a regular diner. The fundamental goal is to satisfy the customer (achieve the business objective), but the pursuit of culinary excellence (creative brilliance) elevates the entire experience. Agencies often see award-worthy work as a benchmark of their capabilities, a way to attract top talent, and a source of pride. It's about understanding that creativity isn't just about winning trophies; it's about problem-solving in the most imaginative and impactful way possible.

The interplay of awards and business results

The eternal debate: does award-winning creativity actually translate into tangible business results? Or are these two outcomes often mutually exclusive, residing in separate silos of agency and client priorities? Both Chattopadhyay and Singh offer reassuring perspectives here. "Some of the best work I’ve seen has both won at Cannes and delivered strong business impact," affirms Chattopadhyay. Singh echoes this sentiment, highlighting that "there are countless examples where award-winning work has directly resulted in an upswing for the brand."

Consider a campaign that not only captures the zeitgeist with its innovative storytelling and emotional resonance but also triggers a significant increase in brand engagement, website traffic, or sales. These are the unicorns of the advertising world—campaigns that manage to strike gold on both the creative and commercial fronts. However, both experts acknowledge that this isn't always the case. Singh aptly notes, "Of course, there will always be instances where it’s not." Sometimes, a brilliantly creative campaign might not perfectly align with the brand's immediate business goals, or a highly effective campaign might lack the avant-garde flair that often catches the judges' eyes at Cannes. The key, perhaps, lies in understanding that while awards can be a fantastic validation of creative excellence, true success lies in achieving the client's objectives, and sometimes, the most creatively daring work is also the most commercially potent.  

The relevance of Cannes Lions

In today's marketing landscape, characterised by an increasing emphasis on data and performance metrics, the relevance of the Cannes Lions for both agencies and clients is a subject of ongoing discussion. Chattopadhyay believes that "In today’s data-heavy landscape, Cannes still matters—it celebrates the power of emotional, human storytelling, but often with effectiveness metrics thrown in as a requirement." This suggests a growing recognition within the industry that creative brilliance needs to be anchored in strategic thinking and demonstrate a tangible impact. The era of purely artistic expression, devoid of business consideration, might be fading.

However, Chattopadhyay also points to a significant shift in the economic realities of the advertising world. "But given the reality of shrinking profit margins in ad land, the huge sums involved in entering awards are increasingly being questioned by CFOs. With agencies downsizing to stay afloat, it is hard to justify a fat awards entry budget—not to mention the ‘junket’ to Cannes that is part and parcel of this award tradition." The financial strain on agencies is leading to a re-evaluation of the cost-benefit analysis of Cannes, both in terms of entry fees and the once-coveted "junket" that served as a significant incentive for creative professionals. The drastic reduction in the number of people being sent to Cannes by top agencies this year is a clear indicator of this changing landscape.

While the allure of the Lion's roar is undeniable, the steadfast focus on the bottom line remains the bedrock of the client's psyche. Agencies, caught in this dance, must navigate the delicate balance of pushing creative boundaries while delivering measurable results, all while keeping an eye on the shimmering possibility of bringing home a piece of that coveted Cannes gold. The festival may be evolving, its relevance being constantly redefined in the face of a rapidly changing industry, but the fundamental human desire for recognition and the enduring power of truly impactful storytelling will likely ensure that the spirit of Cannes Lions continues to resonate, in some form or another, with both agencies and the brands they serve.

News