Mosquitoes Are A Menace, But Eradicating Them Would Only Backfire On Earth — Know Why

When it comes to deadly animals, lions, sharks, and snakes might spring to mind. But the true killer is far smaller — and far more persistent. We will give you a hint: They are tiny, buzzy, and undoubtedly annoying. You guessed it right! They are mosquitoes, the deadliest animals on the planet, responsible for over 7 lakh deaths each year, primarily through the transmission of diseases like malaria, dengue, and yellow fever — as reported by the World Health Organization (WHO).

Given this staggering toll, it might seem logical to dream of a world without mosquitoes. But experts and ecologists argue that such an idea, while tempting, could spell disaster for ecosystems.

Mosquitoes: Menace Or Missing Link?

It’s tempting to think of mosquitoes as pests with no redeeming qualities. But as National Geographic and ecologists point out, their role in nature is more complex than we realize.

"Removing mosquitoes entirely could have consequences we can't predict,” said Ann Froschauer, public affairs specialist with the US Fish and Wildlife Service, in an interview to National Geographic. There are more than 3,500 mosquito species, most of which play key ecological roles — from pollination to serving as essential prey for birds, bats, amphibians, and fish.

In fact, male mosquitoes don’t even bite. They feed on nectar and are important pollinators of plants — including orchids and crops. Mosquito larvae, which live in water, are a vital food source for aquatic animals such as fish and dragonfly nymphs. Even adult mosquitoes are preyed upon by birds, frogs, and bats.

Although bats are often considered one of the primary mosquito predators, Winifred Frick, a bat biologist at the University of California, Santa Cruz, clarified on National Geographic that “there aren’t any bat species that specialise specifically on mosquitoes". Most bats are generalist feeders, and many mosquito species are active during the day, while bats feed at night — limiting their interaction.

Eradicating mosquitoes using tools like pesticides could also backfire, experts warn. “The collateral damage of extensive pesticide spraying could have very dire impacts on bats as well as other wildlife,” Frick added.

In places like Will County, Illinois, explained in an educational article by the Forest Preserve District of Will County, mosquitoes are a part of the complex web of life. Male mosquitoes pollinate plants, and both their larval and adult forms feed a variety of species, linking them to multiple levels of the food chain. Disrupting one link in this chain — even one as pesky as a mosquito — can send ripples across entire ecosystems.

This principle is already seen with species like white-tailed deer, which, when overpopulated due to a lack of predators, can degrade habitats through over-browsing. And similarly, changes in Arctic algae due to climate change affect the entire polar food web — from zooplankton to seals to polar bears.

As Michael Hutchinson, an entomologist with the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture, told National Geographic, not all mosquito species even target humans. Some feed on frogs and amphibians, while others, such as those in the genus Toxorhynchites, don’t bite at all — in fact, their larvae prey on other mosquitoes.

What If We Erased The Killer Mosquitoes?

On the other hand, eradicating just the disease-carrying species could save hundreds of thousands of lives annually. Malaria alone killed over 7 lakh people in 2022, and diseases like dengue and yellow fever claim tens of thousands more.

Encouragingly, we may not need to go full sci-fi to fight back. Scientists are already deploying gene-editing tools like CRISPR, infecting mosquitoes with disease-blocking bacteria, and even sterilising them with radiation to reduce populations without wiping them out.

Scientists are now turning to innovative strategies to control disease rather than eliminate mosquitoes altogether. Approaches like infecting mosquitoes with parasitic bacteria, sterilising them using radiation, and even editing their genes using CRISPR have shown promise in reducing disease transmission without erasing the insect from the web of life.

As disease ecologist Marm Kilpatrick from the University of California-Santa Cruz told National Geographic: “Obviously, if you remove an animal from these ecosystems, something would change… But would the impact be something the average person would notice? I’ll say that we don’t know the answer, but my hunch would be no.”

More Than Just A Bite

Here’s the takeaway: every species, even the most annoying, is part of a vast ecological web. In forests, fields, and wetlands, removing even a tiny insect like a mosquito can ripple across food chains — from pollination to predation and beyond.

So this World Malaria Awareness Day, while it’s okay to grumble over a bite, let’s also acknowledge the bigger picture. The battle against mosquito-borne diseases must be fought with science, not short-sighted extermination.

Because nature, as always, is not as simple as it seems. 

Kirti Pandey is a senior independent journalist. 

health