Elton John Slams UK’s AI Copyright Plan: 'Criminal & A Betrayal'

Five-time Grammy winner Elton John has lashed out at the UK government’s controversial proposal to allow artificial intelligence developers to use creative works without guaranteed compensation for the artists. Calling it “criminal,” the singer expressed dismay at the impact such policies could have on up-and-coming talent in the creative sector.

AI Ambitions Clash With Artist Rights

As Britain positions itself to become a global AI powerhouse under Prime Minister Keir Starmer, the government has suggested a plan to loosen copyright laws. The proposed framework would allow AI systems to train on any legally accessible material unless creators explicitly opt out. Critics argue this puts the burden on artists to police the use of their work rather than on tech firms to seek consent.

For John and other major industry voices — such as Paul McCartney, Andrew Lloyd Webber, and Ed Sheeran — the proposal is nothing short of a threat to the future of creativity. “The danger is for young artists, they haven't got the resources to keep checking or fight big tech,” John told the BBC. “It's criminal and I feel incredibly betrayed.”

“A Machine Doesn’t Have a Soul”

At the heart of the backlash is the belief that AI-generated content, no matter how sophisticated, lacks the emotional depth of human-made art. John, who has sold over 300 million records across six decades, said, “A machine ... doesn't have a soul, doesn't have a heart, it doesn't have human feeling, it doesn't have passion. Human beings, when they create something, are doing it ... to bring pleasure to lots of people.”

The iconic musician, a long-time supporter of Labour, emphasised his commitment to nurturing young talent and said he would keep fighting against the proposed changes.

Government Seeks “Balance” Amid Creative Concerns

While artists decry the proposal as a form of digital exploitation, the UK government insists it is still weighing its options. Officials say they are consulting stakeholders and will publish an economic impact assessment before making any final decisions. "We will not sign off on anything unless it is completely satisfied that they work for creators," the government stated.

The UK’s creative industries have long been a global success story, spanning film, theatre, music, publishing, and advertising. As AI continues to evolve, the battle over who controls and profits from creative output appears far from over.

technology